The panelists thought the muscled-up shark could be Pauly D or David Dobrik.

Warning: This article contains spoilers aboutThe Masked Dancerseason 1, episode 5.

Hammerhead’s time swimming with the sharks is over.

the masked dancer

Credit: Michael Becker/ FOX

The contestant was eliminated inThe Masked Dancer’sSuper Six episode tonight, and unmasked as a certain reality TV star.

but guest panelistWhitney Cummings’feedback summed him up well.

Her flexibility had the panelists guessing celebrities like Gabi Butler ofCheerfame and Olympic gymnast Simone Biles.

Vinny Guadagnino

Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images

But Upton answered, so there went Jeong’s guess.

A few of the panelists were already convinced of Sloth’s identity.

Last was Zebra, who performed to “Mi Gente” by J Balvin and Willy William.

Ultimately, Hammerhead was eliminated, hostCraig Robinsonannounced.

He was unmasked and revealed to be …Jersey ShorestarVinny Guadagnino!