Warning: This article contains spoilers about episode 2 ofThe Challenge: All Stars, streaming now on Paramount+.
Trishelle Cannatella is no stranger to stirring up drama on reality TV.
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Being the first female eliminated fromAll Starsmust not have been an easy experience.
Juan Cruz Rabaglia/Paramount+
TRISHELLE CANNATELLA:No.
[Laughs] It’s tough because my husband is like a big competition punch in of guy.
I just wish that I had trained more.
I thought that people were going to be a little bit less athletically prepared than they were.
Honestly, I just wanted to hang out with everyone and have a good time.
I have seen this elimination before when I did Battle the Seasons.
To me, that was the toughest one.
I was terrified when I saw those jungle gym-bang out things.
I was like, “Nooo!”
And Kendal’s a really hard competitor because endurance-wise, she’s a beast.
Do you wish you had given everyone a name for nominations to avoid going against Kendal?
That’s hard because every single girl in that house was good at something.
I wanted them to just choose because you just never know what your elimination is going to be.
If it was physical, I don’t want to go against Aneesa.
If it’s mental, I don’t want to go against Jonna.
It’s just different, and there’s something that every single person there was good at.
I totally give her all the credit.
I have felt bad about it since the day it happened.
To me, that was the worst.
And unfortunately, I don’t deal with the stress in a good way.
So, yeah, there’s a lot of moments that I regret.
Have you ever reunited with or apologized to Sarah after you quit onRivals 2?
Yes, I have talked to her.
Sarah is just like the kindest person in the entire world.
She was like, “Trishelle, I know that mentally and emotionally you needed to leave.”
She was like, “I wanted what’s best for you in that situation.”
[Laughs] We’re not all terrible people!
Where is the friendship at now?
We haven’t spoken.
I know, and it’s insane.
No one could have seen that coming, not me, not her, no one.
It’s an important situation, but it was a nasty fight.
I think that we’re going to need some time.
It hasn’t been enough time yet.
Do you think you’d still be close if you hadn’t gone onAll Stars?
I don’t think that we would have had that fight.
And it brought out the worst.
Do you regret doingAll Starsbecause of the fight with Katie?
No, because there were so many great moments.
If you were invited back for another season ofAll Stars, would you participate?
If I was in shape, yes.
If I continue to not be in shape, then no.
[Laughs] I need to work out first.
Ask for more money!
[Laughs] I did so many shows that I should have been paid more for.
I think that every show that I did was kind of a growing experience.
And I would say don’t be so honest, but I’m glad I was!
That’s kind of, I guess, a blessing and a curse.
A lot of hate.
I gota lotof hate.
My family did too.
They were very upset.
But I just turned 22 and we were in Vegas, I mean like, we had tobring it.
So that’s what we did.
I wouldn’t say I was proud of myself.
I kind of regretted a lot of stuff back then.
And I think that every young lady should.
I would not have thought he’d be aReal Worldfan.
I didn’t either!
And he knew everyone’s name!
I was like wow, that’s cool.
Celebrities, they sit in their boxers and watch reality TV just like us.
Do you have any other surreal celebrity encounters where you found out someone was a fan of yours?
I heard that Jennifer Aniston was a fan too, and that’s cool.
You just never know.
